Middle Earth SBG: Saruman and Grima Review

 


As part of the Tale of Three Wargamers that I'm doing along with two friends on the Blog (here's a link if you're interested), I picked up the Saruman and Grima plastic kit that was released a couple of years back now. I've got a couple of these new kits for Middle Earth SBG now, and have been impressed with them all, so how does Saruman stack up? As always, I'll be breaking my thoughts down into value, quality, build and looks:

Value: 3/5

As with all Games Workshop kits, you are paying a premium. All 3 miniatures (and the palantir) are squeezed onto a single sprue- which is impressive, but in terms of sheer quantity of plastic- it's not much for £26 if you buy straight from Games Workshop (you can get a discount from a FLGS for this though!) What saves this for me is that you're getting 3 miniatures, and a nice token/scenery piece in the palantir. When you compare this to a Warhammer 40k character sprue, for example, there you are getting just a single model, and sometimes on a smaller sprue, for a similar (if not more expensive) price point. It's a nice touch giving you a dismount for Saruman, a support hero in Grima and the palantir as an extra touch. They definitely could have gotten away without the extras- so it's a nice touch.

Same price- I know which I'd rather have!


Quality- 4/5

The quality is good- of course it is- you're paying Games Workshop prices for the higher end of the market. Why not a 5 then? Mould lines. Mould lines to the point that I was actually surprised. When I build a newer Games Workshop kit, the mould lines are usually very little concern- they're either in places which won't be seen, and places where after you've scraped them off, won't be noticeable. Where are they on this model? Saruman's smooth robes, the legs of the horse, the round end of Saruman's staff, the palantir... I spent the better part of an hour scraping mould lines for this miniature. It's not that other miniatures don't have them- but when I built the Witch King, or Treebeard, there was no where near this much work! There is nowhere near this much work on any of the recent Blood Bowl miniatures either. Perhaps I just got unlucky, but I didn't feel I could give the usual 5/5 for a Games Workshop product after the amount of work that was required.

Unfortunately I hadn't been expecting to take any build photos, so I didn't photograph any of the more annoying mould lines. But I deliberately left the Palantir on the sprue to show the kind of mould line I'm talking about- a smooth surface, the most annoying place to have to clean!

Build- 3.5/5

It was fine. Just fine. The parts went together OK- some small gaps, but easily solved. It wasn't challenging, it wasn't especially satisfying if you enjoy the build. It was the usual splicing of pieces that you see on modern plastic kits designed in a computer. Scraping mould lines probably resulted in the loss of half a point, but it was still fine to build.

You can see a small gap on Grima's foot as an example. Can't say I understand why this needed to be a separate piece- it won't be an issue after some paint is on though.

Looks- 5/5

For me, this is the definitive look for Saruman and Grima. They're just perfect. Grima really with his slimy appearance both in Theoden's court and Orthanc. Saruman is imposing, and the details on the clothing is really great. I'm glad that they're quite static, but just have that little bit of subtle movement to Saruman's pose. For me, the wizards just look better when they're appearance is more reserved- Saruman was commanding, and this model is just that!

Just the perfect Saruman look for me!

Overall- 15.5/20

Overall, I'm extremely happy with the miniature. Most of my issues with it were with the building stage of things- but once you're past that, it's still a good product. As to whether you should rush out and get one, I suppose it depends how much you like Saruman. If you are just starting, and have an interest in Isengard- yes absolutely. If you enjoy painting, I think this is going to be great to paint compared to some of the older Middle Earth wizards (I've painted both Gandalf and old Radagast in the past). If you already own a Saruman though, I'm not sure if I'd recommend it due to the price and amount of clean up required- it would have to come down to how much you love the posing of the models.



Comments

Post a Comment

The Hobby Breakfast Show

The Hobby Breakfast Show Youtube

Popular posts from this blog

Aeronautica Imperialis: Thunderhawk Review

Image
  The Thunderhawk Gunship I had been waiting to get one of these since it was announced last year! Despite a bit of a delay in actually getting my hands on it (out of stock for a while), its finally here- so what is the plastic Thunderhawk like? Value- 2/5 This one was tricky to rate. I have to admit, I had been slightly put off when the kit came out to see a single Thunderhawk for £26 (as of writing, it is about to see a price increase in March 2022). In a way, I view the Aeronautica range a little more like an Airfix kit- part of the joy is seeing the details of the larger aircraft recreated in such a small scale, but the cost of this is vastly higher than an Airfix kit.  Perhaps this is an unfair comparison- how does the Thunderhawk compare to another Aeronautica kit? The Thunderhawk compared with the Grot Bommer The Thunderhawk is large, and if it weren't for the wingspan, is starting to dwarf the Grot Bommers. However, I think the Thunderhawk feels like slightly worse value. F
Read more

Creating Middle Earth SBG Crebain out of AoS Miniatures

Image
  For my Isengard army that I'm currently building, I'm going to be including some Crebain- flocks of crows which Saruman uses as his spies. The first point of call would of course be the official models made by Games Workshop. However, the official models are Forge World- and a little on the pricey side... £27.50 for 2 Crebain flocks... I looked at reviews, which do suggest these are good models- but as I needed 3, I didn't feel I could justify £55 for 2 packs- especially as the rest of the army didn't cost much more than this...  I therefore had a look for some alternatives to make Crebain with- although there weren't a massive amount of crow models out there. I found some individual crow miniatures, but would have had to completely construct a base for them. This was perhaps a bit too much effort for what aren't something that I want to become a time sink. In the end, I circled back to Games Workshop, for some other miniatures they make for Age of Sigmar. The
Read more

Dead Man's Hand Plastic Gunfighters Review

Image
  Welcome back to the blog with my next review: Dead Man's Hand Plastic Gunfighters from Great Escape Games. I picked this box up as a small project for some skirmish gaming in the Wild West (I'd been watching a few Western's recently and wanted to scratch an itch). I'm intending to use the Ruthless rules, which I saw on the LittleWarsTV Youtube channel, and loved the look of these- I generally try to get plastic miniatures where possible (personal preference) and these appeared like good value (£15). So, what are my thoughts on the kit? Value- 5/5 You can't fault the value on this kit- 10 miniatures for £15 is already fairly reasonable, but with the options you get in the kit, this could form the basis for many different kinds of miniatures for miniature games in the West- you could just buy this box and be ready to play a game. The sprues contain twice as many heads as needed, and about twice as many weapons and extras needed too. The only note I would make in reg
Read more

Blood Bowl Sevens- Old World Alliance vs Halflings (S01GW01)

Image
Here it is, the second match of Game Week 1, the Old World Alliance team, the Altdorf Commanders face off against the Halflings team, the Mighty Mootland Mice . As always, punditry and highlights are brought to you by our ex-player commentary team, Brokk Frorson and Thistle Hedgehill. Pre-Game The weather is perfect for Blood Bowl, and with both teams starting undervalued- neither has brought any inducements to play. The Halflings win the coin toss, and elect to receive, and with that the game is off. First Half The Halflings receive the ball, bouncing just in-front of their line, and start to charge up to create an offensive line at the mid-point of the pitch. The initial stages are cagey- the Treeman and Ogre immediately clash, but nothing but a push-back is rolled. Midway through the Half, Dwarf Runner, Thrar Frondison, Blocks a Halfling Hopeful, and Badly Hurts the Hopeful. Brokk: 'With all the heavy hitters on the pitch, you'd never have guessed the Runner would get the fi
Read more

Blood Bowl Sevens- High Elves vs Porklings (S01GW01)

Image
Welcome to the first game of the Sevens Blood Bowl League. Our first fixture today is going to see the High Elf Home Team, the Ellyrion Eagles face off against the visitors, The Blue Reach Boars (Goblins/Porklings). Lets have a look at the Match Highlights, and punditry from ex-players, Brokk Frorson and Thistle Hedgehill. Pre-Game With Perfect conditions for Blood Bowl, both teams arrive fully prepared for the upcoming fixture. The Porklings use the opportunity of some available petty cash to buy a bribe for the referee, and with that- it's time for Kick-Off. Brilliant Coaching is rolled on the Kick-Off table- but a resulting draw leaves neither team with an extra Re-Roll. First Half With a well placed Kick, the Porklings deftly aim the ball into the centre of the pitch- forcing the Elves to come towards them, and the Boar (Troll) straight out of the gate. This immediately paid off for the Porklings, as in their first turn, they were able to Blitz the Boar into an Elf Blitzer, KO
Read more